© 2025 SDPB
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Is This The Worst Play In NFL History?

NFL football players

Follow @Nate_WekSDPB

During the Indianapolis Colts vs New England Patriots Sunday night football game this week, the Colts failed on a play that still feels surreal. It started off as a fake punt, but turned into one of the worst trick plays in the history of the league.

Still laughing. http://t.co/9GnPQXOBDR pic.twitter.com/87znzAL4jv

— SB Nation (@SBNation) October 19, 2015

Indianapolis had the ball at their own 37-yard line and was facing a fourth and three. Yes the Colts were losing by a possession, but it was still the third quarter - which means punting seemed like the most logical option, yes? Wrong - Indianapolis decided to place nine of their eleven players near the sideline, while keeping just a wide receiver Griff Whalen as the snapper and safety Colt Anderson at quarterback.

OK, so maybe Indianapolis was trying to force New England into taking a time-out, but there's one problem - Whalen snapped the ball to Anderson. Once Anderson had the ball, he was immediately gang tackled by a group of Patriots defenders for a loss on the play and a turnover-on-downs.

A flag was also called for an illegal formation by the Colts, which the Patriots instantly declined. The turnover-on-downs stood and New England took possession in Indianapolis territory.

Whether it was the poor decision of Whalen to snap the ball, or just a poor play design/idea in general from head coach Chuck Pagano - nothing about the play was in favor of the Colts.

So what do you think? Was this the worst play in NFL history, or can you think of a worst one?

Nate Wek is currently the sports content producer and sports and rec beat reporter for South Dakota Public Broadcasting. He is a graduate of South Dakota State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Journalism Broadcasting and a minor in Leadership. From 2010-2013 Nate was the Director of Gameday Media for the Sioux Falls Storm (Indoor Football League) football team. He also spent 2012 and 2013 as the News and Sports Director of KSDJ Radio in Brookings, SD. Nate, his wife Sarah, and three sons, Braxan, Jordy, and Anders live in Canton, SD.